American Macaroni Salad
American Macaroni Salad
This is a nice size recipe for a party or honestly whenever I make this recipe because it is even better after a day or two! We eat it with hot dogs and burgers or sandwiches. This is the Mac salad you want at every barbecue or outdoor event!
INGREDIENTS:
4 cups dry elbow macaroni, cooked, rinsed and drained.
1/2 cup diced celery
1/3 cup minced red onion, soaked in cold water for 5 minutes and drained.
3 tablespoons minced flat-leaf parsley
1 cup diced red tomato (preferably Romas)
1/2 cup of diced green pepper (you can use red, orange or yellow too)
1 1/2 cups mayonnaise
2 and a 1/4 teaspoons dry mustard
4 and a half teaspoons sugar
4 and a half teaspoons apple cider vinegar
9 tablespoons sour cream
1 and a 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt
freshly ground pepper
DIRECTIONS:
In a large bowl combine the macaroni, celery, onion, parsley and tomato. In a medium size bowl whisk together the mayonnaise, dry mustard, sugar vinegar, sour cream and salt. Pour the dressing over the salad in the larger bowl. mix well. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Store in the fridge covered for 2 hours before serving…. and lasts 3 days in the fridge once made.
****Sometimes I will chop 3 boiled eggs to add to the salad for more of a lunch or meal BUT you can tweek it however you like! Add carrots and any other veggies you want. The secret is the dressing…. the apple cider vinegar adds a delicious zing and mixed with the sugar in the dressing it is perfect. I use Hellman’s for all recipes including mayonnaise because it just states the best to me.****
35 Comments
Michele Ash
Thanks for the delicious recipe on American Macaroni Salad! I love Macaroni Salad!! My husband prefers Potato Salad, however, I’m crazy over Macaroni Salad!! I try to make it every time we have a cookout or for a get together with friends and we’re eating! I really loved our recipe! I’ve saved it to give yours a try! I make mine without so many different veggies in it! Thanks again for sharing your recipe on American Macaroni Salad with all of us! I truly do appreciate it! Thanks again! Michele 🙂
Edward
This looks so delicious, we love macaroni salad, thanks for sharing the recipe.
Linda Manns Linneman
This macoroni salad sounds so good. I can’t wait to give it a try. Thank you so much for sharing
Edward
I have to try this recipe. Looks delicious.
Cathy Jarolin
My Entire Family loves Macaroni Salad..Your recipe sounds awesome. The apple cider vinegar probably livens the flavor up a bit! Lol!! I will be posting your recipe on pinterest for myself! Thankyou so much for sharing! :0)~~~
Jane Ritz`
I’m a good cook but I make terrible macaroni salad. I’m going to try your recipe step by step. Maybe I’ll have success.
Elizabeth
It’s been so long since I’ve made a Macaroni Salad! This recipe sounds yummy…thanks for posting it! I like your suggestion of adding some hard boiled eggs 🙂
mcushing7
I like to add the egg and eat small bowl of it for lunch! It is delicious! You will love it… I always made horrible mac salad before but this recipe is better than any I have ever had. Enjoy it!
Birdiebee
I have not made macaroni salad for year. This looks like a really delicious recipe.
Lisa Coomer Queen
This looks like a great Macaroni Salad. Will have to try. I have it pinned. Thanks for the recipe.
Edna Williams
Thanks for sharing this recipe! It looks awesome!
Tamra Phelps
I usually make macaroni salad or potato salad around Thanksgiving or Christmas, along with a lot of other stuff, lol, as a side dish for holiday meals. I’ve been told this is nuts, that it’s more of a Summer picnic type food, but my family has always included it in holiday meals.
Robin Creager
This is the exact recipe I’ve been looking for! Thank you..pinning it now.
Joy
Love this stuff! Thanks for the recipe. Pinned it for later.
Sally Wilsey
I love macaroni salad. I like your recipe and will have to try it soon.
Richard Hicks
Looks really good. Want to try it.
Sarah Phillips
This American Macaroni Salad looks delicious and super easy to make! I could see myself bringing it along to Thanksgiving dinner this year. You could even add some seasonal foods like squash or pumpkin. Thanks for sharing <3
Molli Vandehey
my parents alwayas loved macaroni salad and i never did. i would try this recipe and see if i can make it into something i will like
Crystal E.
This looks yummy! I’d like to make this for the next family BBQ!
Maryann D.
I enjoy macaroni salad especially with a sandwich. I do not have a good recipe to follow, but this one looks terrific and we would enjoy it.
Sally Wilsey
This is a new twist on Macaroni Salad. I will definatlly add this to my recipe book.
Brandi Dawn
Yummy, this looks delish! I love a good cold macaroni salad with a nice hot sandwich for lunch!
jo n
I will have to seperate this into 2 batches. My husband likes Miracle Whip and the rest of us like Hellman’s…..and never the twain shall meet.
jo n
I would have to split this batch into two. My husband likes Miracle Whip and the rest of us like Hellman’s….and never the twain shall meet.
Nicole Carter
Oh my gosh I was just thinking of making a macaroni salad and this popped up! It looks very yummy!
Lauryn R
Yum! I love macaroni salad! This recipe looks so easy and delicious, I can’t wait to try it! Thank you for sharing! 🙂
Katherine Riley
I love trying new macaroni salad recipes. The sour cream and tomatoes are a new addition for me,
Jodi Hunter
This looks so yummy!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sandra Watts
It is getting time for some macaroni salad soon. I can’t wait.
Kathleen Kelly
I love this kind of salad, simple and delicious! Thanks for sharing!
Cynthia Mercado
This recipe looks yummy! I will have to make this soon!
Judy Metcalf
This is a very good recipe
Jennifer Benavidez
This sounds good. I love pasta!! I like to make macaroni salad and take it to pot luck dinners or when I go to the lake with the in-laws. Nothing better than macaroni salad and grilled hot dogs! Thanks for the recipe!
Jeffrey
This looks like something tasty that I’d like to serve at a picnic during the Summer.
Jeffrey
Very nice looking recipe. My sister loves macaroni salad, so I think I’ll send the recipe to her to make.